Meghan Markle‘s 45th birthday passed without a public acknowledgment from the royal family, but experts insist the silence was driven by palace protocol rather than an intentional insult. The Duchess of Sussex received no birthday message from King Charles III, Queen Camilla, Prince William or Kate Middleton on the monarchy’s official social media accounts Tuesday.

According to royal commentators, the palace now limits public birthday tributes to working members of the monarchy. However, the absence of a visible message does not necessarily mean Markle received no acknowledgment behind closed doors.

Meghan Markle No Longer Qualifies For A Public Royal Tribute

Royal commentator Tom Sykes explained that Markle’s departure from royal duties changed how the palace handles occasions such as her birthday. “Birthday wishes to a private citizen would be sent privately,” Sykes told Page Six, referring to Markle and Prince Harry’s decision to step away from their royal roles in 2020. “There’s absolutely no way anything will be put on social media feeds or anything like that.”

Royal expert Kinsey Schofield agreed, noting that the royal family has not publicly celebrated Markle’s birthday since she and Harry relinquished their positions as senior working royals. “The Royal Family has consistently reserved official birthday wishes for working royals, and Harry, Meghan, and their children haven’t been included in that policy for several years,” Schofield said. “Palace officials would tell you it’s protocol, not personal.”

The policy means the absence of an Instagram post was not unique to Markle’s 45th birthday. Harry and the couple’s children, Prince Archie and Princess Lilibet, have similarly been excluded from the palace’s official birthday acknowledgments in recent years.

King Charles May Have Reached Out Privately

Although Charles did not publicly acknowledge his daughter-in-law’s milestone, both experts believe he may have sent a private message. “The king is a scrupulously polite man, and I’m quite certain he would wish to send his daughter-in-law his birthday wishes,” Sykes said.

Schofield suggested that the monarch may have instructed palace staff to send Markle a card or gift away from the public eye. “Charles has always had a compassionate streak, and despite everything that’s happened, he has rarely gone out of his way to be overtly unkind toward Meghan,” she explained. “A discreet gesture would be entirely in keeping with his character.”

Whether Charles personally contacted Markle remains unknown. Neither the palace nor the Sussexes publicly confirmed that a private birthday exchange occurred. However, the possibility comes as Harry and Markle appear to be making progress in repairing their strained relationship with the king. The Sussexes reportedly visited Charles and Queen Camilla last month after years of tension between the two sides.

Prince William And Kate Middleton Were Unlikely To Reach Out

While experts believe Charles may have privately recognized Markle’s birthday, they were far less optimistic about William and Kate doing the same. “I don’t think they will be expecting any [birthday wishes] from Prince William and Catherine,” Sykes said.

Relations between the Sussexes and the Prince and Princess of Wales reportedly remain fractured, even as Harry and Markle attempt to reconnect with Charles. Schofield claimed there is now “simply” no relationship between Markle and William. “They believe Meghan played a significant role in the breakdown of family trust, and I think any suggestion that they’re secretly exchanging birthday wishes belongs more in the realm of wishful thinking than reality,” she said.

Neither William nor Kate publicly commented on Markle’s birthday, and there has been no indication that the couple has resolved the conflict that has separated them for several years.

The Duchess Marked Her Birthday With A Playful Post

Rather than addressing the royal family’s silence, Markle celebrated the occasion with a lighthearted post of her own. The “Suits” alum shared two photographs showing her jumping into a swimming pool while holding a bouquet of balloons. “Thank you for the birthday love!” she captioned the images.

Markle did not disclose how she planned to spend the remainder of her birthday. However, Schofield predicted that the As Ever founder would celebrate privately with Harry, their children and close friends. “If they celebrate with friends, I wouldn’t be surprised to see them return to one of their favorite Montecito spots, whether that’s Lucky’s Steakhouse or Tre Lune, both of which have become familiar choices for the Sussexes over the years,” she said.

The commentator also predicted that Markle would use the birthday as a “carefully curated public moment,” something reflected in the polished poolside photographs she ultimately shared.

Meghan Markle’s Royal Birthday Tributes Ended In 2020

MEGA

Markle has not received a public birthday message from the royal family since she and Harry left their royal positions in 2020. The couple subsequently moved to California, where they are raising Archie and Lilibet.

Their departure marked the beginning of an increasingly public rupture with the monarchy. Interviews, documentaries and Harry’s memoir exposed private disagreements and allegations about life inside the institution, further damaging the family’s trust.

The Royal Experts Dish On Why Meghan Markle Was Snubbed On Her 45th Birthday first appeared on The Blast